In a powerful and trending address, Supreme Court Justice BV Nagarathna has sent a clear message to judges across the country: Prioritize the rule of law over the convenience of those in power. Speaking at the Justice T.S. Krishnamoorthy Iyer Memorial Oration in Kerala on March 3-5, 2026Justice Nagarathna who is slated to become India’s first female Chief Justice in 2027—emphasized that the true strength of a judge lies in their ability to make the “right decision,” regardless of potential professional or political consequences.
Independence Over Careerism: The “Judicial Dharma”
Justice Nagarathna’s speech addressed the critical need for an independent judiciary that acts as a check on executive power.
Fearless Decision-Making: She urged judges not to be intimidated by the executive or “those in power.” A judge’s loyalty, she argued, belongs solely to the Constitution and their oath of office.
Ignore Personal Advancement: In a particularly striking comment, she advised judges not to worry if a bold or “unpopular” ruling affects their career progression, elevation, or chances of promotion.
The Power of “No”: She observed that in the face of temptations or institutional pressure, the simplest and strongest response for a judge is to say “No.”
On the “Subtle” Threats to Press Freedom
Beyond the courtroom, Justice Nagarathna also spoke about the “Fourth Estate” during a recent journalism award ceremony. She highlighted that the modern threat to media freedom is no longer just direct censorship.
Economic & Structural Control: She warned that “subtle” methods—such as manipulating advertising revenue, complex licensing laws, and concentrated media ownership—are being used to stifle independent voices.
Reader-Supported Media: She championed the subscription model, stating that a press sustained by its readers is better placed to serve the public interest and fend off political pressure.
Separation of Powers: A Shield Against Arbitrariness
The Justice also touched upon the controversial practice of “bulldozer justice,” reinforcing the principle of Separation of Powers.
Due Process: She emphasized that determining guilt is a judicial function. If the executive demolishes a citizen’s home based solely on an accusation without a trial, it effectively “collapses the constitutional scheme.”
Judicial Review: She described judicial review as the mechanism that ensures the “Basic Structure Doctrine” remains more than just a slogan, keeping legislative and executive actions within their limits.
Read More: Forget Your Promotion, Do What’s Right Justice B.V. Nagarathna’s Viral Message to Judges
Comments are closed.