A surprising kitchen staple makes all the difference.
Key Points
- Laura Bush’s deviled eggs get a silky texture from the addition of butter.
- Habanero hot sauce adds a Texan-inspired kick to this classic appetizer.
- Garnish with paprika, parsley or bacon bits to customize this festive recipe.
From Martha Washington’s famous fruitcake to Mamie Eisenhower’s Million-Dollar Fudge, first ladies have a long tradition of contributing to White House culinary history by leaving behind iconic recipes. And there’s one hiding in the official archives that you won’t want to skip this holiday season.
While Laura Bush’s recipe for deviled eggs contains just five main ingredients, making it quick and easy to recreate, two surprising mix-ins set it apart from traditional recipes. The secret to the first lady’s classic starter is none other than butter and hot sauce—she is from Texas, after all.
Adding a touch of butter is a simple way to level up this traditional appetizer, contributing a super silky mouthfeel and doing wonders for presentation. Softened butter gets blended in a food processor along with the cooked egg yolks, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard and hot sauce, plus salt to taste. The mixture is then piped with a star tip into the halved egg whites. That decorative form can easily lose its shape when using only mayo as a binder, so the butter can also help add a little structure to your finished product. As the assembled deviled eggs chill in the refrigerator, the butter adds some firmness to the filling and prevents the mixture from becoming overly soft or weeping.
As for the hot sauce, the recipe notes that the Bushes are partial to Yucatan Sunshine Habanero Pepper Sauce, even introducing it to the White House kitchen. The recipe also notes that the hot sauce can be substituted with a vinegary sauce like Tabasco—which might be a better option for those who prefer a little less heat.
The flavor layering doesn’t end there. Bush’s recipe says to sprinkle the deviled eggs with paprika and chopped parsley—everyday ingredients that add even more flavor and color. To get creative and make this recipe your own, try adding your favorite hot sauce, and chives or crispy bacon bits as garnish. You could also do like the former first lady and experiment with the amounts of mustard and hot sauce until you land on your ideal combination of flavors.
Bush may have released this Texan-inspired deviled egg recipe for the 2003 Independence Day celebration, but it’s a delicious side dish to serve anytime of year. After chilling them in the fridge for at least an hour, simply arrange them on a festive platter for your holiday guests to enjoy. Don’t be surprised if they disappear in seconds—deviled eggs with a kick can be that good.
If you’re in the market for other ways to put a twist on your deviled eggs during the holidays, you might try making other festive additions, like using avocado in your filling or even adding a little crabmeat. And there are plenty more classic appetizers that are well worth adding to your holiday spread—here are a few of our favorites: