A Delhi court has dismissed a plea by a sitting Haryana judge seeking the transfer of a bail application hearing for an accused, alleging bias by the presiding judge. The female judge claimed that the remarks made by the judge in the order rejecting the accused's initial bail application affected her status, as her name was explicitly mentioned.
The case concerns a cheating allegation involving approximately Rs 52 lakh directed against the Haryana judge. The Delhi Police Special Cell has registered a First Information Report (FIR) in connection with the matter.
Principal District and Sessions Judge (PDSJ) Vijay Kumar Dahiya of Patiala House Court rejected the transfer petition on November 13, describing it as lacking any substantial evidence. He stated, “If a request for transfer of bail application such as this, alleging, without an iota of material, bias on the part of the judicial officer, is to be entertained, it would be impossible for a judicial officer to function dispassionately or discharge their duties without fear or favour.”
Judge Dahiya further ruled, “This court thinks that no ground is made out for transfer of second application of the respondent/accused for grant of regular bail. Accordingly, the present transfer petition filed by the petitioners is dismissed and disposed of.”
The petition was filed jointly by the Haryana judge and her domestic help on the basis that certain observations made during the bail hearing adversely affected the judge. These observations have been challenged in the Delhi High Court, where the matter remains sub judice.
According to the court, “The petitioners have admittedly no genuine bona fide case of bias against the concerned Judge. A case of bias is being sought to be built up merely because some observation has been made by the concerned Judge against petitioner/judge while disposing of the bail application of respondent/Accused and against the said. Observation: petitioner/Judge has taken legal course by filing a Criminal Writ Petition before Hon'ble High Court of Delhi.”
Judge Dahiya emphasized the seriousness of bias allegations, stating, “Allegations of bias against a judicial officer are not to be lightly made. Even issuance of notice on such an application has serious deleterious repercussions for the judicial officer concerned in as much as every judicial officer is expected to act without fear or favour.”
One petitioner is a serving judicial officer in Haryana, and the other is her household help. Both are victims of an alleged cyber fraud involving approximately Rs 52 lakh, and an e-FIR has been lodged relating to the losses they suffered.
The court noted that an order dated June 9, 2026, on the accused Deepak Vats's first regular bail application repeatedly disclosed the judge's name and identity in bold and underlined text, making it accessible on the Case Information System (CIS) portal. The order's public availability led to widespread circulation on media and social media platforms, resulting in articles and posts concerning the judge's private life and professional standing.