Washington: A US federal court has canceled the Trump administration's rule, under which a provision was made to limit the period of stay in America for foreign students, researchers, teachers and journalists. The court considered this policy arbitrary, unfair and not in accordance with the law.
District Judge F. Dennis Seller said in his order that the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) failed to present sufficient grounds and evidence to implement this rule. The court struck down the final rule published on July 17, 2026 under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). Also, while accepting the petition of the petitioners, the government's petition was rejected.
This rule was to apply to international students coming on F-1 visa, researchers, professors and teachers on J-1 visa and foreign journalists holding I-1 visa.
The court said that the Department of Homeland Security could not prove how the new rule would help prevent fraud and national security risks. The Department also did not adequately consider alternatives to the existing system and did not respond appropriately to concerns raised in public comments.
Questions also raised regarding SEVIS system
The court also considered the role of the already existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) for monitoring foreign students and institutions. Under this system, educational institutions provide information related to foreign students and report their status.
According to the court, the Department of Homeland Security has previously been using this system to identify fraud and violations of visa rules. Yet the Department failed to explain how it would be more effective to introduce a new, fully discretionary visa renewal process for foreign students after four years in the United States.
The petitioners included several organizations related to higher education and immigration, teachers' organizations and representative organizations of journalists.
The court also said that the new rule could have affected the higher education of foreign students. This could create barriers to longer courses like PhD, joint degree programs and changing subjects during studies.
The court noted that the US Congress intended to provide educational opportunities to foreign students through the F-1 visa program. The Department of Homeland Security cannot claim unlimited authority to weaken this program in the name of national security and fraud prevention.
Earlier, on September 14, 2026, the court had issued a preliminary order staying the implementation of the rule. The US government appealed against this decision to the First Circuit Court of Appeals. This appeal was pending at the time of the latest order.