The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that there are no strict rules under which only women police officers can “handle” women during crowd-control operations. The submission followed petitions alleging that women protesters and journalists were manhandled during demonstrations seeking the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar.
Petitions challenge police handling of women protesters
The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, India, represented by advocate Aarthi Rajan, along with the Delhi Union of Journalists, Free Speech Collective and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists.
In its affidavit, the police said the rule requiring women officers to conduct searches or arrests involving women did not apply in the same way to crowd-control duties.
Also Read: Watch | Delhi police protest: Cop-vs-cop row a sign of simmering discontent?
“With regards to the allegations of manhandling of women journalists, it is respectfully submitted that the requirement of women personnel handling women is not a statutory mandate in the context of crowd-control operations, in the same manner as it is expressly prescribed under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 in relation to searches and arrests,” the police said, reported The Hindu.
Police defend deployment of male officers
The police said deployment depended on propriety, avoiding unnecessary confrontation and defusing tensions, especially where women were present. It further stated that the presence of male officers at the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) protest did not, by itself, amount to misconduct, adding that a male officer could act as a first responder or assist a woman colleague.
“Such decisions have to be taken at the fraction of a second,” stated the affidavit.
Police distinguish journalists from content creators
The affidavit addressed the Supreme Court’s October 11 direction that Delhi Police should not “hinder” journalists, lawyers and other professionals performing their duties. The police said this did not cover reel-makers, social media influencers or people defying lawful instructions at a prohibited assembly.
The force said it “fully respects the role of the press”. It alleged that some people with cameras and microphones posed as journalists at the “illegal” protest site.
Also Read: Three women journalists allege sexual harassment by Delhi Police at Jantar Mantar protest
The latter were not obstructed unless they posed a risk to public order and law, stated the police, arguing that existing laws did not classify content creators as “working journalists.”
It said it remained unclear whether “reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters”. The lack of a clear legal distinction, it argued, hampered crowd management during the July march towards Parliament, which it called an “unauthorised” protest, with thousands taking part.
‘Personnel maintained restraint’
The police said personnel had maintained restraint. Anyone detained because of mistaken identity was released after verification, it said.
Also Read: CEC resignation protest: Delhi Police register 3 FIRs over Jantar Mantar stir
“The police action was directed solely towards dispersing and removing the protestors from the illegal protest sites and restoring public order, and was neither intended nor directed towards detaining, restraining or obstructing any media personnel in the lawful discharge of their professional duties,” stated the Delhi Police.