CJI’s big comment on SIR… Controversies increased in Bengal, process remained calm in other states

Tezzbuzz Desk – An important observation has come to light during the hearing of the SIR (Special Intensive Revision) case related to West Bengal in the Supreme Court of India. Chief Justice Justice Surya Kant said that the SIR process has been completed smoothly in almost all the states of the country except West Bengal and there was not much litigation on this issue.

Court’s concern about Bengal

During the hearing, the CJI clarified that the SIR process in West Bengal is still incomplete, which is a matter of concern. Citing a news report, he said that despite different political parties being in power in other states, this process was completed without any major controversy.

What is the argument from the state?

The lawyers appearing on behalf of the West Bengal government argued in the court that the ‘logical inconsistency’ is being seen only in Bengal and due to this the matter has become more complicated. At the same time, senior lawyer and TMC leader Maneka Guruswamy demanded to extend the date of freezing the voter list, so that those whose names have been removed can get a chance to lodge objections and be included again.

The court has not yet given any final decision on this demand, but said that it will be considered if necessary. Also, the next hearing of the case has been postponed till April 1.

Electoral Background

Voting for the 294-seat assembly in West Bengal is scheduled for April 23 and 29, while counting of votes will take place on May 4. In such a situation, the ongoing legal debate regarding the SIR process can have a direct impact on the election preparations.

As per instructions issued earlier, around 60 lakh names were marked as ‘under adjudication’ in the post-SIR electoral roll. At the same time, according to the Election Commission of India, the names of about 29 lakh voters are included in the supplementary list, on which the decision has been taken by the judicial authorities.