During the purchase and sale of real estate in India, people often resort to cash transactions due to convenience or other reasons, but this small carelessness can cost you dearly in the eyes of the law. Recently, one such shocking and eye-opening case related to the Income Tax Department and the Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has come to light, where a person had to deal with his house and took Rs 11 lakh in cash in return. Considering that the rules were ignored, the Income Tax Department imposed a huge penalty of the same amount i.e. Rs 11 lakh on the seller. After this legal battle, there has been a stir among the people doing cash deals in the real market and this matter has become the main topic of discussion among tax experts these days.
The entire matter is related to the strict provisions of the Income Tax Act. As per the rules, the Government of India is continuously taking strict steps to curb black money and promote digital transactions. Under Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, it is clearly provided that if a person accepts in cash an amount of Rs 2 lakh or more from a single person in a single specified transaction or in connection with the sale of a single property, then the same will be considered illegal. In this case, the seller selling the house had taken a total amount of Rs 11 lakh in cash from the buyer. When this financial transaction came on the radar of the Income Tax Department, the department imposed the same penalty of Rs 11 lakh on the taxpayer under Section 271DA.
After the Income Tax Department imposed a huge penalty of Rs 11 lakh, the aggrieved landlord challenged the order in the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). During the appeal, it was argued on behalf of the taxpayer that this transaction was not done with any malice or for the purpose of tax evasion, but was done under mutual consent and trust between both the parties. However, during the hearing, the tribunal made it clear that ignorance is not a pardonable offense in the eyes of law. ITAT upheld the stand of the Income Tax Department under which a clear violation of Section 269ST was found. However, barring logical relaxations in some cases, the severity of penalties on cash transactions was completely maintained under the strict provisions of the law, sending a clear message that those who compromise financial transparency will not be spared.
This entire legal episode is a big lesson for all those citizens, property investors and common people of the country who do not see any harm in giving or taking a little cash during registration or agreement. Experts say that while buying and selling property, one should always use banking channels like account payee cheque, demand draft (DD) or digital means like net banking, RTGS and UPI. If you are even slightly careless and make a big cash transaction against the rules, then the Artificial Intelligence (AI) based systems and data scrutiny of Income Tax catches it immediately, after which not only you may have to pay heavy fine but also get entangled in lengthy legal process.