Supreme Court: Big decision! 'Supreme' strike on land acquisition, permission of gram sabha must be obtained before acquiring land for industries

  • An attempt to acquire land by opposing the Gram Sabha
  • The Supreme Court ruled the acquisition process illegal
  • Prior approval of Gram Sabha is mandatory

 

If the land of a village is to be taken for industry, then the opinion of the Gram Sabha will not be ignored. In particular, prior consent of Gram Sabha is mandatory for acquisition of land in Scheduled Areas. No one, be it the government or a private company, can take over the land arbitrarily if the gram sabha clearly opposes it. Supreme CourtThis legal point has been re-emphasized in a recent landmark decision. (Supreme Court)

This decision directly affected the Dalmia Cement project in Sundargarh district of Odisha. The land acquisition for the project has been canceled by the Supreme Court.

The process was going on despite the opposition of the Gram Sabha

A bench of Justice Dipankar Dutta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma delivered the verdict on November 18. Two gram sabhas of the respective villages had passed a resolution on January 26, 2020, opposing the land acquisition. However, the administration continued its process.

Supreme Court on Foreign Divorce: Foreign divorce invalid in India; An important judgment of the Supreme Court

Interestingly, consent in 'Form M' as required by Odisha rules was also not obtained. Therefore, the court clarified that this process of acquisition does not fit within the framework of the law.

80 percent consent is required for private companies

Section 41(3) of the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 requires the prior consent of the concerned Gram Panchayats before acquiring land in scheduled areas.

Apart from this, the consent of at least 80 percent of the affected families has to be obtained as per Section 2(2)(b) while acquiring land for a private company. This consent must be taken along with the Social Impact Assessment (SIA) process. The court also clarified that the earlier legal error cannot be rectified by obtaining consent later.

There were also issues of lack of public hearing in this case and the inclusion of a consultant related to the company in the expert group. This raised questions on the transparency of the entire process.

The land does not belong to the company because of the mining lease!

Even though Dalmia Cement has got mining license, it does not end the rights of private landowners. The court held that a mining lease agreement between the government and a company cannot affect the ownership rights of a third party on the land.

Finally, the Supreme Court set aside the judgment of the Odisha High Court and quashed the land acquisition notifications and related orders. However, the government has been allowed to start the acquisition process afresh by fulfilling all the conditions of the law.

This decision has given important legal strength to the rights of gram sabhas in scheduled areas and the land rights of local citizens.

Supreme Court News: Why the delay in the process of appointing judges? Supreme Court Notice to Central Govt

Leave a Comment