In Punjab and Haryana, debate erupts every year on the pollution caused by burning of stubble left in the fields after harvesting. By the time November arrives, its effect becomes visible on the air of Delhi-NCR. In such a situation, a plan was made to stop pollution caused by stubble burning and set up a 2G ethanol bio-refinery plant. For this, the foundation stone of 2G Ethanol Bio-Refinery was laid on 25 December 2016 in Bathinda, Punjab. Almost 10 years have passed, production has not yet started from this plant.
On the other hand, Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) also set up a 2G ethanol bio-refinery plant in Panipat, Haryana. This plant was dedicated to the country by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on 10 August 2022. According to IOCL records, its commissioning took place in April 2023, while commercial production started from 11 November 2023.
In such a situation, a big question arises that why the foundation stone of the 2G ethanol bio-refinery plant in Bathinda, Punjab, which was laid in 2016, could not start production even after almost 10 years? Whereas a similar plant has been started in Panipat, Haryana and commercial production has also started. In these 10 years, the project cost of the plant increased by about Rs 821.46 crore.
Also read: Question on cost in Adani Green project, why is there an uproar?
Almost 10 years have passed, production has not started
Government reports show that the foundation stone for the 2G ethanol bio-refinery plant in Bathinda was laid in December 2016. This project is being prepared by Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL). Its objective is to produce ethanol by using agricultural residues like paddy and wheat straw. Even after almost 10 years, commercial production has not started here.
During this period the cost of the project increased from Rs 600 crore to Rs 1,421.46 crore. In June 2019, HPCL's board approved a revised cost of ₹1,421.46 crore. Initially the project was estimated to cost around ₹600 crore. For this, a plant with the capacity to produce 100 kiloliters of ethanol per day (KLPD) was proposed.
The work on the plant has been delayed due to changes in technology and design and requirement of equipment. However, once again the target was given to start commercial production by December 2026. Even before this, production dates have been fixed many times. In such a situation the question arises whether the wait will end now
The biggest reason for delay in the plant
A major reason for the delay in this plant was change in technology. This is clear from the documents of the July 2020 meeting of the Environment Ministry's Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC). The technology on which HPCL had initially planned to build the plant was not meeting the set standards. According to the company, the old technology was not able to meet the performance guarantees in terms of consumption of water, electricity, other essential commodities and ethanol production.
Additionally, there were deficiencies in the detailed engineering design of the technology (BEDP) and certain equipment. Basic Engineering Design Package i.e. BEDP, this is the basic engineering design of the plant, in which the complete outline of machines, equipment, technology and working of the plant is decided. HPCL decided to adopt new technology in place of old technology. For this, a technology was chosen, which had already been used in small demonstration plants.
The impact of changing technology was not limited to machines only. Due to this, changes had to be made in the design of the plant, land, water and electricity requirements. Earlier, 15.1 hectares of land was earmarked for the plant, which had to be increased to 20.9 hectares. For this, 5.8 hectares of additional land was required. This land was with HPCL since March 2019 and was to be used for storing stubble.
Due to changes in plant equipment and technology, capital costs and operating expenses also increased. The environment ministry committee had also raised questions on the technical and economic feasibility of the project as well as water requirements. Thus, due to changes in technology the project had to be redesigned. In such a situation, the deadline for starting it was also affected.
Also read: From mobile to medicine, how much did PLI scheme change India's business in 14 sectors?
How did the cost reach from Rs 600 to Rs 1,421 crore?
When its foundation stone was laid in December 2016, it was estimated to cost around Rs 600 crore. However, later due to changes in technology and equipment, HPCL fixed the revised cost of the project at Rs 1,421.46 crore. That means a total increase of Rs 821.46 crore. In such a situation, the cost of the plant became about 2.37 times the initial estimate. In June 2019, the board of HPCL had approved this revised cost.
Contrary to the Bathinda story, Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) also set up a 2G ethanol bio-refinery in Panipat, Haryana. This plant was dedicated to the country by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on 10 August 2022. The installed capacity of IOCL's plant is also 100 kiloliters per day (KLPD). In such a situation, its capacity is equal to Bathinda plant. But the situation of both the plants is in front.
IOCL's plant was commissioned in April 2023 and commercial production began on 11 November 2023. Talking about the cost, according to the information given along with the answer to a question asked in the Lok Sabha on February 5, 2026, the total expenditure was Rs 984 crore, out of which about 76 percent i.e. about Rs 749 crore was spent on equipment and construction.
What is the status of Bathinda plant?
There has been a delay in this plant. The March 2026 project monitoring report of the Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation (MoSPI) said that 95 percent of the work on the plant had been completed. Now we have got the timeline of 31st December 2026. The date was given several times before this. The work was to be completed by August 2021. In the press release issued by the Environment Ministry on November 2, 2023, it was said that the plant was expected to start by the end of the same year but it did not happen.
After this, news of starting the plant by the end of March 2024 came out, once again time passed. Now it is said that this plant will start in December 2026. In such a situation, it remains to be seen whether this plant will start now or whether the deadline will be extended due to some reason.