How Vietnamese property tycoon sold illegal houses to 519 buyers

Le Thanh Than, former chairman of property
giant Muong Thanh Group, allegedly defrauded 519 customers by building and selling condos without permits at
a project in Hanoi.

Than, also the former general director of
developer Bemes, is accused of deceiving 519 buyers who paid a total of VND531.8 billion (US$20.5 million)
for apartments and townhouses at the CT6 Kien Hung project in Kien Hung Ward (previously part of Ha Dong
District).

His trial began on Wednesday and is expected
to go on for 13 days. Prosecutors have recommended a suspended sentence of 30 to 36 months for the
76-year-old.

They also want him to compensate buyers based
on the units’ market prices, which stood at VND53-56 million per square meter as of July.

Prosecutors said Than had given instructions
to advertise the project as fully approved and the selling price as inclusive of the cost of a title deed,
leading buyers to believe they would have legal ownership of the units they bought. But due to various
violations during construction, the 519 units have not been granted title deeds.

The master plan for the project was approved
in 2008, with Bemes as the developer. The approved plan included two towers comprising 231 apartments and
459 hotel rooms, a commercial podium, 15 low-rise townhouses, and a kindergarten.

Prosecutors said Bemes made unauthorized
changes during construction, including adding floors, changing the buildings’ functions, and erecting a
third tower.

Starting in 2011, Than allegedly put out
false advertisements about the project’s legality and signed contracts with customers promising that “the
project has been approved,” the selling price “included the cost of title deed,” and the developer would
“assist buyers with the necessary procedures” to get their title deeds.

Upon completion in 2012, the development had 1,620 apartments and townhouses, of which
934 have been issued title deeds.

The 519 units without title deeds include apartments in the third tower and on floors
whose functions were changed, and townhouses that were not part of the approved plan.

At a court hearing in 2023, Than had argued that only the buildings’ functions had been
changed while their structures remained intact, and that the damage calculation was unreasonable.

Than later admitted wrongdoings and explained that, “out of haste to seize business
opportunities,” he had not completed the procedures to amend the plan in time.

To remedy the consequences, Bemes agreed to buy back 39 apartments in the third tower.
Lender BIDV said in April that it would provide Bemes with a VND1 trillion credit line to pay compensation.

CT6 is just one of 12 projects in southern Hanoi linked to Muong Thanh that were found to
have violations.

Only 6,759 apartments were approved for construction at those projects but 24,943 were
built, according to a report by the Hanoi People’s Committee.

Leave a Comment