The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has said that a series of constitutional and legislative changes made in Pakistan have consistently weakened the independence of the judiciary and have effectively placed the country’s top courts under the control of the executive.
The Geneva-based organization said in its report released on Wednesday that these changes have seriously affected the ability of the judiciary to constrain the government and provide justice to victims of human rights violations.
The report titled ‘Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments’ analyzes the existing framework relating to the High Courts, the Supreme Court and the Federal Constitutional Court in the context of international legal obligations. This report has been released after the implementation of the 27th constitutional amendment in November 2025 and the 26th constitutional amendment in October 2024.
ICJ Secretary General Santiago Canton said that both these amendments have brought the supreme courts of Pakistan under the control of the executive. He said that when courts come under government control, there is no one left to hold the government accountable and victims of rights violations have no effective platform to seek justice.
According to the report, these amendments and the manner of their implementation have deprived Pakistan’s top courts of the judicial independence required by Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the UN Fundamental Principles of the Independence of the Judiciary.
The ICJ has also linked this decline in the independence of the judiciary to the broader erosion of democracy and human rights in Pakistan. The organization says this also impacts the right to an effective judicial remedy under Article 2(3) of the ICCPR, to which Pakistan is a party.
Canton acknowledged that Pakistan’s judiciary was in need of reform. He noted the lack of transparency in the appointment process of judges and in some cases interference by courts in the jurisdiction of other institutions, although he said that instead of addressing these problems, the government used public dissatisfaction with the courts as a pretext to take them over.
The ICJ has demanded that those provisions of the 26th and 27th constitutional amendments, which are not in accordance with international standards related to the independence of the judiciary, be amended or repealed.