India vs New Zealand: How Basin Reserve's History Makes Batting Fourth Extremely Difficult

The Basin Reserve in Wellington is infamous for its unforgiving conditions for batsmen. Out of 70 games played in the ground since 1930 (nearly 100 games of Test cricket), no team has been able to chase down a total of over 274 runs.

Although it seems from these figures that teams batting second have enjoyed far more success (30 wins to only 16 for teams batting first), only a handful of these wins were achieved in a nail-biting game in the fourth innings. Most of them were relatively easy victories after beating down the opposition in the first innings and chasing a small target. Due to an average score in the first innings of 313, it pays to play patiently in order to take advantage of swing and make a large first innings total, so that Wellington's infamous westerly wind can work its magic in the final stages.

In an extreme place, some of the highest scores in New Zealand cricket history have taken place at this ground, including 680/8 declared in 2014 against India. However, the lowest score in New Zealand cricket history was also posted here, when New Zealand were all out for 42 in a game against Australia in 1946. If the ball goes into a swing at this ground, chasing totals rapidly becomes very difficult.

The Rare Feats: History's Highest Chases in Wellington Ft. India vs New Zealand

Only 4 scores of 200+ runs or more have been made in fourth innings at the Basin Reserve.

274 – Pakistan made the largest score in the history of the ground. They were heavily outplayed for the first 2 days of this match after New Zealand had put on 366, but managed to come back to win the match by 7 wickets, scoring 277/3.

234 – Just 3 months later, Graeme Smith's South Africa team got very close to this record. Chasing 234 (after New Zealand had scored 297 and 252), Smith (who had scored 47 in the first innings) played an outstanding innings of 125 to take South Africa home with 6 wickets in hand.

217 – The 2017 Test Match was one of the most bizarre matches ever played at the Basin. While Bangladesh batted first and scored an impressive 595/8 declared, they still lost this match. New Zealand got off to a strong start with 539 runs. In the 2nd innings of Bangladesh, New Zealand played exceptionally to knock them out of the game. They then easily chased down 217, losing only 3 wickets in total.

213 – It is clear that chasing under 200 runs in Wellington can be very dangerous. After a huge 356-run total in their 2nd innings, India set New Zealand a target of 213. However, Craig McMillan (74) and Chris Cairns (61) used the pitch conditions at the end of the day to win the game for New Zealand by 4 wickets.

All-Time Highest Successful Run Chases at the Basin Reserve

Target score Chasing Team Opponent Year Result
274 277/3 Pakistan new zealand 2003
Won by 7 wickets

234 234/4 South Africa new zealand 2004
Won by 6 wickets

217 217/3 new zealand Bangladesh 2017
Won by 7 wickets

213 215/6 new zealand India 1998
Won by 4 wickets

178 181/1 new zealand Australia 1990
Won by 9 wickets

174 177/4 Australia new zealand 2000
Won by 6 wickets

164 166/4 new zealand West Indies 1969
Won by 6 wickets

Only two further successful chases of over 130 runs have occurred below this figure. South Africa made 148 in 1932, and New Zealand made 133 in their match with Sri Lanka in 1983. Even the 178-run chase with only 1 loss by New Zealand to Australia in 1990 was after they had bowled Australia out for only 110.

Also read: Kagiso Rabada's Heroics Against Bangladesh Show Why Gujarat Titans Retained Him for IPL 2027

What it Means for This Match Between India and New Zealand

With Shubman Gill and Tom Latham facing each other at the Basin Reserve, both sides will look to the history of this ground and see that any fourth-innings total above 250 runs has essentially been impregnable for nearly a century.

Tactically, this means that whichever side gains a lead in the first innings will likely take their time in setting a target. To leave the opposition needing around 230 to win would essentially create an impregnable fortress at this ground, particularly given the funnel effect created by the wind direction in the North. In addition, there is enough swing in the later stages of games to make scoring boundaries seem as though they were near impossible.

India will take note of this. Their best score at this ground came in the 2014 draw, where they scored 438. However, when they last played in 2020, they were comprehensively beaten, losing 10 wickets in only 4 days. Along with 1998, Gill knows that setting them in the low 200s is extremely risky.

However, with Bumrah leading the pace attack, alongside Siraj and Prasidh Krishna, India can decide who will face the chase. Given the nature of the Basin Reserve, whoever is forced to face a chase will very likely lose.

Leave a Comment