Martin Lewis explains when to switch heating off to save money

As the heating season gets underway, the timeless debate resurfaces once again — is it more cost-effective to keep your heating running throughout the day, or switch it off when the house is empty? The argument in favour of the “low and slow” approach proposes that keeping radiators at a consistently modest temperature across the day yields superior energy efficiency.

Energy bills have risen by £60 a year from October after Ofgem increased the energy price cap by 4%. This amounts to an extra £5 per month for the average household. The energy price cap will climb to £1,723 a year for the typical household for those not on a fixed tariff who pay by Direct Debit in England, Scotland and Wales. This is up from the £1,663 cap currently in place, a rise of 4%. That figure applies to the typical household, however.

Yet not everybody is persuaded. Martin Lewis’ Money Saving Expert has stepped in to resolve the debate once and for all.

Drawing on expertise from the Energy Saving Trust, British Gas, an independent plumber and MoneySavers social media, this represents the most thoroughly researched answer available.

The conclusion appears to be that “leaving the heating on all day leads to greater heat loss and means higher cost”, according to MSE.

That said, there are compelling points on both sides of the argument — and the correct answer may depend on your own personal circumstances. The Energy Saving Trust argues that leaving the heating on throughout the day is the less efficient option.

Its guidance is simple: only warm your home when you genuinely need it, ensuring you pay exclusively for what you consume.

Fitting a programmable thermostat is commonly considered the most efficient method to maintain your home at the ideal temperature at times that suit you. That being said, if you have a contemporary boiler or heat pump, work from home, or spend the majority of your evenings and weekends indoors, Heat Geek argues that the low and slow strategy proves superior.

Heat pumps are a low-carbon type of electric heating that extract warmth from the outdoor air, while a modern condensing boiler, installed after 2005, recovers some waste heat before it escapes.

In these circumstances, maintaining a consistent indoor temperature of 18 or 19°C may prove more cost-effective. Sustaining lower temperatures with gentle heating – meaning you avoid raising the thermostat whenever you sense a chill – enables the boiler to reclaim more waste heat during the process.

Nevertheless, this technique may not suit everyone if you are frequently away from home or have plasterboard walls, which typically warm up considerably faster. Conversely, if your property has cavity wall and loft insulation or underfloor heating, the low and slow strategy is the one to adopt.

Some also advocate for maintaining heating on low and constant, contending that it stops moisture accumulating within the walls each time the system is turned off – which can drain heat from your property while also promoting the development of damp and mould.

Given that there isn’t a definitive solution, MSE suggests a trial and error method – measuring your energy consumption with each approach.

Record meter readings at the beginning and conclusion of each testing period and evaluate the outcomes, ensuring the temperatures during the weeks under comparison are as alike as possible.

Leave a Comment