Rahul Gandhi’s remarks about the affectionate relationship between his parents, Sonia and Rajiv Gandhi, at the launch of his mother’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Lovehave triggered a political confrontation between the Congress and the BJP. What began as a personal recollection has turned into a wider debate about family values, expressions of love, patriarchy and individual freedom.
The BJP criticised Rahul’s remarks, questioning their compatibility with Indian culture and traditions. Rahul subsequently responded by sharing an image of a sculpture depicting Shiva and Parvati, accusing BJP and RSS supporters of allowing fear, anger and hatred to prevent them from experiencing love.
In this conversation on daily YouTube show Capital BeatThe Federal’s Political Editor Puneet Nicholas Yadav spoke about why the controversy has escalated, how the BJP’s response has helped the Congress frame the debate, and whether Rahul is finding resonance among younger voters.
What do you think has really irritated the BJP ecosystem about Rahul Gandhi’s tweet?
There are three basic points that need to be made about this entire episode and what Rahul Gandhi said. When he was saying what he was saying, the second half of his statement is what completes the story. The occasion was the launch of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, and it’s a very personal account. Almost 400 pages out of its 503 pages are largely about Rajiv and Sonia Gandhi and their personal life.
What Rahul said at the book launch was a contrast between how he saw his mother while growing up and what happened after tragedies began striking the family, beginning with the assassination of Indira Gandhi and subsequently that of Rajiv Gandhi.
When he talks about seeing his parents deeply in love and mentions that he would see Sonia sitting on Rajiv’s lap at the dinner table or during meals, he is describing what his mother was like, what their household was like, what his parents were like and what they grew up with.
Also read | ‘She belonged to my father’: Rahul’s ‘epilogue’ completes Sonia’s story of belonging
Immediately afterwards, he says that all of this disappeared in an instant. Those were the words he used. First, with the assassination of Indira Gandhi and then, some years later, with his father being blown to bits. That was when Sonia Gandhi changed completely as a person.
That is the context. It is not as though Rahul suddenly decided to talk about his parents’ romance. He was trying to draw a contrast between what he saw of his parents while growing up and what his mother subsequently became, and why.
The second point is that you can take what Rahul is saying at face value and brush it off as something typically Rahul. It is an unconventional thing for a politician to say. It also reflects his willingness not to worry about how people are going to react.
But didn’t Rahul anticipate this kind of reaction from the BJP? Wouldn’t his team have told him that speaking about something so personal and unconventional could provoke such a response?
As far as I know, it was not a prepared speech that had been discussed with his team and Congress office-bearers beforehand. I think the BJP, through the reactions that have come from its leaders, has walked into a trap.
Whether it is Himanta Biswa Sarma, Pankaj Chaudhary, the BJP president in Uttar Pradesh who is also a Union Minister of State for Finance, or the party’s official Twitter handle, the way they have reacted and jumped on this, thinking they are doing some great service to their own cause, has given the Congress and Rahul Gandhi an opportunity to turn the argument back on them.
♦ Overlooked second half of Rahul’s statement provides the context to what he said
♦ Rahul tends to be an unconventional politician
♦ By making a hue and cry, the BJP has exposed its own regressive thinking
If the BJP had not reacted, nothing would have happened. It was not as though people were taking to the streets and protesting against what Rahul had said. It is the BJP that tried to manufacture a controversy, and now it is going round in circles trying to deal with it.
That brings me to my third point. By going back to this very regressive, orthodox and patriarchal position of the BJP — questioning whether these are our sanskar and insisting that what happens at home should stay at home and that such things should not be discussed in public — the party has exposed its own thinking.
The underlying message is that love cannot be discussed openly. These are the kinds of things that the BJP appears to be uncomfortable with.
Himanta Biswa Sarma has also criticised the Congress for sharing pictures of Shiva-Parvati and Vishnu-Lakshmi to defend Rahul’s remarks. He said the Congress had suddenly become Sanatani, with gods and goddesses everywhere. How do you see these reactions?
Well, I think that is not really a party you associate with reading. So, it is a good thing if they are reading Sonia Gandhi’s book. They might find some education there.
But coming back to the point, what the BJP has effectively done by reacting the way it has is allow Rahul and the Congress to turn this into a clash between two narratives. If you go through Rahul’s tweet, his narrative essentially says that he, as a leader, and his party, as a political organisation, stand for a progressive and liberal society. In such a society, your choices, the way you live, whether inside or outside the house, whom you love, how you love and how you lead your life are your decisions.
This is opposed to the BJP’s idea, where every personal choice is something that the political elite of the day should regulate.
Also read | Sonia Gandhi’s memoir: What she reveals and what she leaves unsaid
I don’t need to list the number of instances of moral policing by the BJP, the RSS and their various affiliates. What you eat, what you wear, how you are supposed to love, whom you are supposed to love and whom you are going to befriend — all of these fall within that ecosystem and its ideology.
I don’t think this is the time for that kind of politics. We are hearing so much about young people, Gen Z and political parties trying to reach out to this particular demographic. I think the BJP is doing a great disservice to itself and its great leader by still not learning any lessons.
If you go out and tell Gen Z that you are not supposed to talk about love, that you are not supposed to talk about your friends or how you behave at home, I doubt any of them are going to be enamoured by you. That is the message and the difference Rahul is trying to establish between what his party stands for and what the BJP stands for.
The entire Hindu angle, the Hoysala temples and everything else are incidental to this. It is not about that. I think the issue has gone beyond it.
During the NEET paper leak protests, we saw young people, including children from BJP families, coming out to protest. Has Rahul stirred the hornet’s nest with this tweet? Could his remarks create discussions and even fissures within BJP families?
I would not want to jump the gun and say how people from BJP families would react. But when you look at the Gen Z protests over examination paper leaks and the subsequent protests over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR), there have been instances of children from BJP families — including children of MPs, MLAs and ministers — publicly saying that they do not agree with what their parents or the political party their parents represent are doing to this country.
I am quite sure that even if you do not see a public outpouring of support from these quarters for what Rahul has said, it will become a point of discussion within their homes.
Also read | How Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging, reveals the person behind the enigmatic Congress leader
And consider the timing. On the same day, in fact yesterday, the Supreme Court gave a free pass to the rapists in the Bilkis Bano case by suspending their sentences.
Are you trying to tell me that the BJP and people in the BJP are comfortable with rapists roaming the streets? Are we comfortable with marital rape and all kinds of other crimes against women, including rape, molestation and sexual harassment?
The NCRB data, particularly from BJP-ruled states, will tell you a story about how the BJP fares in controlling these kinds of crimes.
We are also seeing visuals from Mumbai of people tearing pages from Sonia Gandhi’s book because it reportedly contains negative references to Veer Savarkar. How do you view these protests, especially when the BJP has been questioning Rahul Gandhi’s remarks on family values and Indian culture?
This is typical outrage from people who have nothing to do with history or education. They have nothing to say about anything that can even remotely be construed as progressive thought or a liberal idea. They get riled up by a book mentioning something about Savarkar, even though none of it is unsupported by historical documentation.
What Savarkar stood for, what his ideology was and what he meant politically or socially are not things that you need Sonia Gandhi’s memoir to understand. There are reams and reams of documentation available to tell you exactly what Savarkar stood for, and none of those ideas should actually have a place in a democratic society.
Watch the video here.