We’re pulling our slow cookers out for this one.
Reviewed by Dietitian Maria Laura Haddad-Garcia
Key Points
- Sunny Anderson’s slow-cooker pasta is hearty, customizable and packed with nourishing ingredients.
- The dish uses store-bought tortellini and meatballs for an easy weeknight meal.
- Opt for low-sodium broth and swaps like turkey sausage or evaporated milk for a lighter meal.
Have you noticed that slow-cooker recipes have gotten a major glow-up? Once just a device for making pulled pork and pot roast, the slow cooker is now a vessel used to create restaurant-worthy meals, and we’re here for it. This shift can be seen everywhere—from home cooks on social media to influencer blog posts.
Even experienced chefs are inspired, including Food Networks’s Sunny Anderson, who recently appeared on The Drew Barrymore Show to make her slow-cooker Creamy Tuscan Meatballs & Cheese Tortellini. Anderson says it’s a dish she makes all the time, and we think we will too.
The recipe begins with browning store-bought meatballs and Italian sausage in a skillet with some olive oil. Sunny explains to Drew that this is a cosmetic move that gives the meat “color,” but it also adds “texture” and “deepens the flavor.” This step is also a good place to make adjustments—go with all meatballs or all Italian sausage, if you like, or swap in plant-based replacements to make the recipe vegetarian.
While the meat is cooking, the pair starts building the base of the dish in the slow cooker by adding a blend of spices including oregano, black pepper and red chili flakes. Next, Sunny adds chicken stock, noting that vegetable or beef stock or broth will also work, and a can of crushed tomatoes. The browned sausage and meatballs are added to the slow cooker along with some garlic, onions, Parmesan cheese and chopped sun-dried tomatoes.
Sunny gives it a big stir, then covers the slow cooker with a lid and sets the temperature to low. It takes about three to four hours for the flavors to develop and the liquid to thicken, then the dish is ready for the finishing touches. Those touches include adding a package of refrigerated cheese tortellini, fresh spinach and a big splash of heavy cream.
We love this simple dish that’s perfect for any weeknight meal. It’s hearty, thanks to the protein from the sausage and meatballs, but it’s also nourishing—after all, the fresh spinach offers calcium, iron and plenty of vitamin K, while the onions and garlic offer anti-inflammatory benefits. To round out the meal even more, we recommend serving alongside a big, leafy green salad or roasted broccoli rabe and zucchini.
Since the dish can be high in sodium, consider using a low-sodium broth or stock and opt for unsalted crushed tomatoes. If you’re watching your saturated fat intake, you could try swapping beef meatballs for plant- or poultry-based meatballs and substitute the Italian sausage with Italian sausage made with turkey or chicken. You could also consider using a spinach-filled tortellini for extra veggies or using evaporated milk in place of the heavy cream for a lighter touch.
If you’ve been looking for a reason to use your slow cooker, now you’ve got one! Sunny’s recipe isn’t just easy, it’s creative and better-than-basic! With a tiny bit of prep you can have a deliciously satisfying restaurant-worthy meal any night of the week.