Supreme Court refuses to hold separate hearing on election commissioners appointment dispute, says bench of five judges will consider

New Delhi. The Supreme Court on Friday refused to hear a petition separately. In this petition, there was a demand to reconsider the law of 2023, under which the Chief Election Commissioner (CJI) and Election Commissioners are appointed. In fact, in the case challenging this law, a bench of two judges had given different opinions. Now there was a demand to withdraw this divided decision and reconsider the matter.

Read :- Relief to Azam Khan from Supreme Court, refusal to interfere in ED's petition at present

What did the bench say?

A bench of the Chief Justice of India (CJI) said the 'recall' application, as well as any petition challenging the reference order, can be considered by a five-judge Constitution bench that has already been constituted to hear petitions challenging the validity of the 'Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Tenure) Act, 2023'.

When can an application for withdrawal of a decision be considered?

The CJI also said that a five-judge bench can consider a 'recall application' even if one of the judges of the bench which gave the 'split verdict' retires.

Read :- Lawyer said- You are not fit to sit on CJI chair, Chief Justice had asked you to wait for the hearing.

What did Bhushan say?

Bhushan said that this 'recall application' should be placed before the same original bench, comprising Justice Dipankar Dutta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, which had given this 'split verdict' on September 23. He told that Justice Sharma is going to retire next week. Bhushan further said that there is a situation of 'conflict of interest' in the case of Justice Sharma, hence this petition for withdrawal of the decision should be heard by the same bench.

What did the CJI suggest?

When the CJI suggested that the 'reference bench' (the bench that forwarded the case) could consider this application, Bhushan said that the 'reference order' itself had been withdrawn due to the allegation of 'conflict of interest'. However, the CJI said that the issue can be raised before the five-judge Constitution bench that has been constituted to take a final decision on the constitutional challenge to the 2023 law.

This development comes after the 'split verdict' given by Justice Dutta and Justice Sharma on September 23 to decide whether a larger bench was needed to consider petitions challenging the 2023 law.

Read:- Supreme Court's big decision in Bilkis Bano gang rape case, life imprisonment of two convicts stayed, bail also granted.

What was the objection?

The main objection was that the CJI was excluded from the panel that selects the Chief Election Commissioner and election commissioners. This panel now includes the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a cabinet minister. Justice Dutta believed that this challenge could be decided by a bench of two judges, while Justice Sharma was of the view that in view of the important constitutional questions involved, it should be sent to a 'Constitution Bench' of five judges.

Leave a Comment